← All stories

Careers & Training

Beyond Memorizing the Rules: Training Officers to Explain Their Decisions

An October IACP presentation challenged police trainers to connect legal rules, tactical skills and the reasoning behind decisions, while acknowledging limits in the evidence for training outcomes.

OfficerList editorial headline graphic, not an incident photograph.
OfficerList editorial headline graphic, not an incident photograph.

Knowing a legal standard is not the same as recognizing how it applies when a call changes unexpectedly. That distinction was the focus of an IACP 2026 presentation by Arif Alikhan and Thomas Datro, described in Police1's October 28 coverage from Orlando.

The training feature offers a practical question for field training officers and supervisors: Are exercises developing an officer's judgment, or mainly testing recall? This is a look at an October conference discussion, not an announcement of a new mandate or a newly proven training program.

Alikhan, a former federal prosecutor and former Los Angeles Police Department director of constitutional policing and policy, and Datro, identified by Police1 as LAPD's director of police training and education, argued for connecting legal rules and tactical skills to the purpose of police action. Their emphasis was on the reasoning that comes before a decision, rather than an explanation assembled afterward.

What changes when the scenario changes?

According to Police1, Datro distinguished between learning information, retrieving it and applying it. A recruit can succeed at the first two while struggling with an unfamiliar situation. The presenters' concern was that a practiced response can become a default even when the circumstances call for reassessment.

One training example involved a driver running from a traffic stop. Datro described pausing an exercise to ask what officers might overlook by immediately following, including another person remaining in the vehicle. The point was not a blanket instruction against pursuit. It was to make officers identify the objective and competing risks before treating the most visible development as the only problem.

Alikhan also challenged the assumption that technically proficient action necessarily means a successful operation. His hypothetical example involved officers carrying out a search smoothly at the wrong house. It was an illustration of the difference between executing a task and accomplishing the right mission, not a reported incident.

Read the facts behind the familiar case

The discussion used Graham v. Connor to illustrate why memorizing a phrase is not enough. The Supreme Court's May 15, 1989 decision addressed the constitutional standard for excessive-force claims arising during an arrest, investigative stop or other seizure of a free citizen. It directed courts to use the Fourth Amendment's objective-reasonableness standard rather than a substantive due-process test.

The case arose from an encounter involving Dethorne Graham, who had diabetes and was experiencing an insulin reaction. In recounting the evidence in the light most favorable to Graham at that procedural stage, the opinion described his hurried visit to a convenience store, an officer's suspicion and a subsequent stop. The Court did not simply deliver a slogan detached from a factual dispute.

The opinion also stressed the perspective of a reasonable officer at the scene and acknowledged that officers may have to make split-second decisions. Reading the circumstances and reasoning together gives instructors more to discuss than a case name alone. This historical example is not a complete statement of current use-of-force law or a replacement for jurisdiction-specific legal instruction.

A large training effort, with an important evidence limit

Police1 reported that Alikhan and Datro helped Chicago develop constitutional-policing instruction about vehicle and pedestrian stops. They prepared instructors who subsequently trained approximately 11,000 officers, according to the presenters' account.

That reach should not be confused with demonstrated effectiveness. The presenters acknowledged that the department had not rigorously evaluated the training's impact on policing outcomes. The reporting therefore supports describing an instructional approach and its reported scale, not claiming that it reduced injuries, litigation or unconstitutional stops.

Alikhan recommended a framework familiar in legal education: identify the issue, identify the applicable rule, analyze the facts and reach a conclusion. In the presentation, the framework was a way to organize thinking, not a substitute for tactical proficiency or legal knowledge.

OfficerList perspective: improve one debrief

A manageable starting point is one scenario and one debrief. Ask the officer what problem they believed they were solving, which facts mattered at that moment, what authority applied and what would have caused them to reconsider. Keep the discussion tied to information available during the encounter rather than facts learned later.

These are editorial suggestions for applying the discussion, not findings from an evaluation. Supervisors can distinguish a learning objective from an outcome claim: practicing a clearer decision process is worthwhile to examine, but any claim of better field performance needs evidence. The central question is whether training helps officers choose an appropriate action, not merely describe an action convincingly after it happens.

Reporting note: This article draws on Police1's conference coverage and the Supreme Court opinion published by Cornell's Legal Information Institute. OfficerList did not attend the session or independently evaluate the Chicago training.

Sources and reporting note

This summary is based on the reporting linked below. OfficerList did not independently investigate the incident.