← All stories

Leadership & Policy

Flagstaff’s $8.9 million crash settlements put return-to-duty decisions in focus

Reported settlements resolve claims from two crashes involving one former officer. The return to driving remains unexplained, while federal guidance offers a framework for reviewing duty decisions.

OfficerList editorial headline graphic. Not an incident photograph.
OfficerList editorial headline graphic. Not an incident photograph.

Flagstaff and its municipal insurer have agreed to $8.9 million in settlements over two crashes involving the same former police officer, according to a 12News investigation. The reporting brings renewed attention to an unresolved leadership question: how the department decided the officer could resume driving after an earlier collision and a restricted return-to-work clearance.

The settlements resolve civil claims. They are not admissions of liability or wrongdoing, according to the agreements described by 12News. That distinction matters when assessing what the payments establish, and what they leave unanswered.

Two crashes, separate claims

12News reported that $8 million will resolve wrongful death claims brought by the family of Hassan Ibrahim, who died in a September 20, 2025, collision involving former Flagstaff officer Jacob Buckwald. A separate $900,000 agreement resolves a lawsuit brought by Dustin Royal, who survived a June 28, 2024, crash involving Buckwald.

In the earlier collision, the officer's marked police vehicle struck Royal's stopped Jeep near Route 66 and Fourth Street. The department initially described the crash as resulting from a sudden medical emergency, according to 12News. Royal later sued, alleging negligence by the officer and department. Those allegations should not be confused with findings reached at a trial.

The station reported that doctors cleared Buckwald to return to work in December 2024 in a non-driving capacity. He subsequently returned to full patrol duties. Approximately three weeks after that return, the second collision killed Ibrahim, according to the report. Police later announced that Buckwald had resigned for medical reasons.

What the payments do and do not show

The City Council approved the settlements in August, according to 12News. The newly reported dollar figures are therefore not evidence that the council approved the agreements this week. Police1 covered the amounts on November 13, drawing on the station's investigation.

The agreements identify the Arizona Municipal Risk Retention Pool as the funding entity. The Ibrahim settlement includes roughly $5.75 million in upfront payments and $2.25 million for structured payments to surviving beneficiaries over several decades, 12News reported.

The report does not establish how much Flagstaff will ultimately bear through its own budget or future insurance contributions. Describing the entire $8.9 million as an immediate city-budget expense would go beyond the available information.

More importantly, the payment totals do not explain the decision-making that preceded the fatal collision. According to 12News, the department had not explained in its responses to the station why Buckwald was returned to driving. OfficerList has not independently reviewed the medical records or settlement agreements and is not making a medical-causation finding.

The broader return-to-work framework

Separate federal guidance provides context for agencies reviewing their own processes. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission explains that medical inquiries and examinations during employment generally must be job-related and consistent with business necessity. Its guidance applies to covered employers, including state and local government employers with at least 15 employees.

The EEOC describes a reasonable belief based on objective evidence that a medical condition will impair essential job functions or create a direct threat as grounds for an appropriate inquiry or examination. When an employee returns from medical leave, the scope must be limited to the information needed to determine whether the employee can work.

The guidance also addresses conflicting medical opinions. It recommends evaluating factors such as the professionals' expertise, the information each supplied and its consistency with the employer's observations. This is general employment guidance, not an EEOC finding about Flagstaff or a substitute for a case-specific legal assessment.

OfficerList analysis: make the assignment decision explicit

For police leaders, the practical distinction is between permission to return to some work and clearance for a particular assignment. A process worth reviewing should identify the actual duties being authorized, any restrictions, who resolves uncertainty and who records the final decision. Driving a patrol vehicle should not disappear inside an undefined label such as returning to duty.

That review also needs boundaries. Safety concerns call for relevant evidence and qualified assessment, not assumptions about every employee with a medical condition. Supervisors need usable duty restrictions, while medical inquiries should stay within their lawful purpose.

Flagstaff's settlements close covered civil claims without admitting fault. The broader management question remains whether an agency can show how medical information, assignment requirements and supervisory decisions fit together before an officer resumes safety-sensitive work.

Sources and reporting note

This summary is based on the reporting linked below. OfficerList did not independently investigate the incident.