Careers & Training
Beyond attendance: trainers make the case for purposeful police practice
A November 13 trainer interview examines decision-making, short practice sessions and follow-up. The recommendations are professional opinions, not measured safety outcomes.

A November 13 Police1 interview with two veteran trainers puts a practical question before police supervisors: does training help officers understand their decisions, or mainly rehearse compliance with an instructor? The discussion argues for purposeful practice, clearer explanations and a stronger connection between formal instruction and daily preparation.
The interview features Paul Costa, an active-duty law enforcement officer whose background includes SWAT and instruction, and Rick Hogg, a former U.S. Army Special Operations service member who provides law enforcement training. Both are members of Safariland’s CADRE. Police1 published the discussion as part of its Officer Safety Week coverage and identifies Safariland as the week’s sponsor.
That context matters. Their observations are professional opinions from a sponsored editorial series, not findings from a controlled study or an audit of departments nationwide. The interview offers ideas worth examining without establishing how common the described problems are or proving that a particular practice reduces injuries.
Understanding the reason behind the repetition
Hogg criticizes training environments where officers are told to follow a procedure without learning why it matters, when it applies or how changing circumstances affect its use. He also raises concerns about settings where questioning an instructor is discouraged. His point is not simply that officers need more repetitions; it is that repetition without understanding can leave them poorly prepared for situations that differ from the exercise.
Costa focuses on decision-making and ownership. He says officers must develop confidence in making reasonable decisions with incomplete information and adapting as circumstances change. He also offers broader criticisms of current police culture and preparedness. Those assessments are his perspective, rather than evidence that today’s officers as a group are less capable than earlier generations.
OfficerList analysis: an instructor can make the distinction concrete by asking an officer to explain the information behind a decision, what remains uncertain and what new information would prompt reassessment. The purpose is to examine reasoning, not reward a confident answer regardless of its quality. Such a discussion should remain grounded in agency policy, applicable law and qualified instruction.
Short sessions need a defined purpose
Asked what an agency could do with ten minutes before a shift, Costa recommends structured firearms practice under proper safety procedures, with specific objectives and attention to deficiencies. He emphasizes consistency rather than repetition performed merely to complete a requirement. Hogg suggests using short sessions for a range of practical skills and keeping a record of progress.
Neither answer establishes that ten minutes is a sufficient training allocation or a universally effective dose. Costa himself notes that a short session cannot meaningfully develop every skill an officer needs. His expectation that regular practice can improve proficiency is a training recommendation, not a quantified outcome demonstrated by the interview.
OfficerList analysis: for supervisors, a useful starting point is to define what a short session is meant to accomplish before putting it on the calendar. That might include reviewing a policy decision or identifying a topic requiring additional instruction. Attendance alone cannot show whether an officer understood the material. Any physical or equipment-based exercise needs approved supervision, facilities and safety controls; an article is not a substitute for those requirements.
Individual effort and agency responsibility
Costa places substantial weight on officers taking ownership of their development, while also saying departments are responsible for quality training, sound leadership and the resources officers need. Hogg calls for meaningful after-action reviews that identify both successful performance and opportunities to improve.
OfficerList analysis: those ideas are most useful when considered together. Encouraging personal commitment should not become a reason to overlook access to instruction or leave officers to resolve identified gaps without support. A supervisor reviewing performance can ask what practice was available, what feedback was given and what follow-up is actually scheduled. These are editorial recommendations, not a description of a program evaluated in the source interview.
The value of the discussion is its emphasis on purposeful preparation rather than a promise of a quick fix. Departments considering changes can distinguish participation from demonstrated learning, document what needs improvement and revisit it with qualified instructors. The next useful question is not simply whether training occurred, but whether its objectives and follow-up are clear.
Reporting note: This feature is based on Police1’s November 13, 2026 interview with Paul Costa and Rick Hogg. OfficerList conducted no independent interviews. Trainer views are attributed above; paragraphs labeled OfficerList analysis are editorial interpretation. No injury reduction or other measured operational outcome is claimed.
Sources and reporting note
This summary is based on the reporting linked below. OfficerList did not independently investigate the incident.